The lab · Final year of high school and beyond (general science culture)
Flip, roll, spin: why your phone never turns the same way
Throw your phone spinning around its length: it turns cleanly. Make it tumble end over end: it goes off askew and flips over by half a turn. It's not your hand shaking. It's a theorem of mechanics, made famous by a cosmonaut in 1985.
Three ways to turn
Looping names each throw after the axis the phone turns around the most:
- the roll (a barrel roll): around its length, like a rolling pin;
- the flip: end over end, around its width;
- the spin: flat, around the axis perpendicular to the screen, like a frisbee.
Moment of inertia: the resistance to turning
For a turning object, mass isn't enough: what counts is how it's spread around the axis. That's the moment of inertia. The farther the matter is from the axis, the bigger it is, and the more effort it takes to make the object turn fast. For a solid block of mass m, whose sides perpendicular to the axis measure a and b:
I = m (a² + b²) / 12a and b: the two dimensions perpendicular to the rotation axis
| Figure | Dimensions around the axis | Moment of inertia (kg·m²) | Compared with the roll |
|---|---|---|---|
| Roll | 71.6 and 7.8 mm | 0.000073 | × 1 |
| Flip | 147.6 and 7.8 mm | 0.000309 | × 4.2 |
| Spin | 147.6 and 71.6 mm | 0.000381 | × 5.2 |
A real phone isn't uniform (battery, screen), but the order stays the same: small for the roll, medium for the flip, large for the spin.
That's why Looping's record is a roll: with the same flick of the fingers, a roll turns much faster than a spin. It's also in a roll, and only in a roll, that the iPhone 16 reached its gyroscope's ceiling during our measurements.
The middle axis is unstable
A theorem of mechanics, called the “tennis racket theorem”, states that a free solid turns stably around its axis of smallest and of largest moment of inertia, but not around the intermediate axis. For a phone, the intermediate axis is the flip's. The slightest flaw in the throw grows, and the phone starts to twist: it does a half turn on itself while it tumbles, then comes back, again and again.
In 1985, aboard the Salyut 7 station, cosmonaut Vladimir Djanibekov saw a wing nut that, spinning in weightlessness, flipped itself over at regular intervals. The effect has carried his name ever since. Your phone in a flip is the pocket version.
You can see it without breaking anything
Take a book held shut with a rubber band and toss it up over a bed, turning it around each of its three axes. Around the middle axis, it flips over every time.
Your turn to calculate
Try first, then unfold the answer. All the data is in the article.
1. With the same rotational energy E = ½ I ω², how many times faster does a roll turn than a spin?
Show the answer
ω is proportional to 1 / √I. The ratio is √(0.000381 ÷ 0.000073) = √5.2 ≈ 2.3: the roll turns 2.3 times faster for the same effort.
2. A paperback measures 18 × 11 × 2 cm. Which is its unstable axis?
Show the answer
Compare a² + b² for each axis. Around the axis through the cover (dimensions 18 and 11 cm): 445, the largest. Around the 18 cm length (dimensions 11 and 2): 125, the smallest. Around the axis parallel to the 11 cm side (dimensions 18 and 2): 328, the intermediate one. The book tumbling end over end around this axis starts to twist.
3. Why is a phone's moment of inertia in a roll so small?
Show the answer
Around its length, all the matter stays within 3.6 cm of the axis (half of 71.6 mm), whereas in a flip or a spin it reaches out to 7.4 cm (half of 147.6 mm). The moment of inertia depends on the square of these distances.